Large file transfer alternative
Signiant vs Aspera
Compare IBM Aspera and Signiant Media Shuttle — and discover why many have already chosen MASV as a faster and more reliable alternative.
Signiant vs. Aspera: Transfer Speed (UDP vs TCP)
Products like IBM Aspera, Signiant Media Shuttle, and FileCatalyst are all User Datagram Protocol (UDP)-based solutions.
UDP guarantees fast transfers, making it an attractive option for those with large multimedia files.
However, due to the nature of UDP-based file delivery, while fast transfers can be achieved, they are overshadowed by a series of complications brought on by this protocol. These complications are important to remember when comparing UDP solutions such as Aspera vs. Signiant vs. FileCatalyst:
UDP-based file transfer platforms are complicated to use. They aren’t accessible across different browser types and operating systems, which can present a learning curve for users.
UDP-based solutions are notorious bandwidth hogs that can slow down your entire network and are often subject to ISP throttling and firewall issues.
UDP is a connectionless protocol, meaning that if data packets don’t arrive, arrive corrupted, or with other errors, they are not re-sent, leading to reliability issues.
Total Cost of Ownership
Providers like Aspera and Signiant require special software, servers, updates, patches, and ongoing support by IT teams. This brings high startup, maintenance, and training costs.
Why MASV’s TCP-based file transfer is superior to UDP
MASV offers the same speed and performance as Aspera and Signiant, with the ease of modern web-based solutions that run on TCP (HTTPS):
MASV has custom acceleration technology and access to 300+ global servers to close the gap between sender and recipient and speed up TCP-based delivery.
Sending a big file through MASV is as easy as sending an email. You can use a browser or our desktop app for added speed and performance.
Improvements to cloud and networking technology means TCP-based transfer can now reach or exceed UDP speeds with an emphasis on fairness and data integrity.
Web technology is always up-to-date against security threats — and MASV brings two-way file encryption, custom security features, and ISO 27001 certification for added protection.
5. Total Cost of Ownership
No IT support or training needed. Just sign-up and start sending large files right away.
📖 Free Guide: How to Determine the Best File Transfer Tool?
Evaluate UDP-based file transfer and web-based solutions against the five principles of file transfer: Simplicity, speed, reliability, security, and total cost of ownership.
Signiant vs Aspera: Pricing
|MASV PAYG||Signiant Media Shuttle||IBM Aspera PAYG||IBM Aspera Advanced|
|$0.25/GB||$7,500/year + overages||$0.95/GB||$10,440/year + overages|
What MASV offers:
MASV is just $0.25/GB downloaded. You only pay for the data that gets used. Uploads are free and there is no per-seat pricing. Custom plans are available to suit your needs.
Signiant vs. Aspera: Security
Both Signiant Media Shuttle and IBM Aspera are secure and offer built-in security for data transfers, including password protection and encryption both in-flight and at-rest.
But UDP-based file transfer isn’t inherently secure due to its many customizations. UDP file transfer doesn’t inherit the security features of modern web browsers, unlike web-based transfer solutions. That adds up to a need for ongoing monitoring and patching by IT resources.
What MASV offers:
- Certification under ISO 27001.
- TLS 1.2 in-flight, AES-256 encryption at-rest.
- A verification from the Trusted Partner Network.
- Password protection, file expiry, and download limits.
- File delivery tracking
- Vulnerability scanning.
Signiant vs. Aspera: User Experience
Both Signiant and Aspera have straight-forward user interfaces to upload and download files. Both tools require third-parties to have their own account to access files, which is a time-consuming process and confusing for those not familiar with the product.
Aspera offers a browser plugin that needs to be 1) manually installed by the user and 2) maintained by the provider.
What MASV offers:
- Upload and downloads from any browser on desktop and mobile devices.
- A free desktop app with added performance, stability, and exclusive features like Multiconnect.
- The ability to download files or upload to a MASV Portal without an account.
- A clean and simple drag-and-drop interface.
Signiant vs. Aspera: Storage
Signiant Media Shuttle customers can connect to their own Amazon S3, Google Cloud, or Microsoft Azure Blob storage, or directly to on-premise storage.
IBM Aspera doesn’t offer storage with its pay-as-you-go plans, but users can buy à la carte storage at a rate of $0.03/GB.
Standard plan subscribers receive 1 TB of cloud object storage. Advanced and Enterprise subscribers receive 10 TB and 25 TB of cloud object storage, respectively.
What MASV offers:
- Free storage for seven days, no matter the size of the file.
- Direct integrations with over 15 different cloud storage vendors.
- Automated delivery into third-party cloud storages.
- Extended storage for $0.10/GB a month (after the first seven days).
Signiant vs. Aspera: Automations
Both Signiant and Aspera offer file transfer automations to speed up file delivery workflows.
Signiant Media Shuttle offers automated workflows through its Media Shuttle API. They’re not out-of-the-box and users must rely on a technical resource for development. Third-party applications can be purchased to add automations but they require an SDK.
IBM Aspera’s automations are available in the Advanced and Enterprise plans. These automations are also limited to either five (for Advanced subscribers) or 10 concurrent workflow jobs.
What MASV offers:
- Free automation features for all users.
- Upload, download, and send to cloud automations.
- The ability to create as many automations as you need at no extra cost.
- A simple interface to create automations without engineering support.
Signiant vs. Aspera: Customer Service
Signiant Media Shuttle support is accessible through a searchable help centre, along with phone and email support for admin and enterprise users.
IBM Aspera support is a top complaint among users. It requires users to access self-serve portal and sift through mounds of support documentation. The transfer client and Aspera’s desktop application must be fully installed for users to access the customer support portal.
What MASV offers:
- Email, phone, and live chat support.
- Priority support and custom pricing for MASV Plus customers.
- A feedback forum for users to submit feature requests and report bugs.
- Help documentation.
Compare Media Shuttle vs. Aspera vs. MASV
|Feature||MASV||Signiant||Aspera PAYG||Aspera Advanced|
|Package limit||No limit||No limit||No limit||6 TB/year|
|Set file expiry date||✅||✅||✅||✅|
|Set download limits||✅||❌||❌||❌|
|Configure user roles & permissions||✅||✅||❌||❌|
|Receive downloads without an account||✅||❌||❌||❌|
|Upload to Portal without an account||✅||❌||❌||❌|
|No charge to create account||✅||❌||✅||❌|
|Send files to email||✅||✅ *||✅ *||✅ *|
|Custom metadata forms||✅||✅||✅||✅|
|Desktop app||✅||✅ **||✅ **||✅ **|
|Cloud Storage delivery||✅||✅||✅||✅|
|Unlimited file transfer automations||✅||✅||❌||❌|
|Custom Portal branding||✅||✅||❌||❌|
|Storage included||$0.10/GB||No storage||$0.03/GB||10 TB|
|Live chat support||✅||❌||❌||❌|
|Free trial sign-up||✅||❌||✅||✅|
*Email recipients require an account.
**Desktop app required.
MASV: A Better Alternative to Signiant and Aspera
Able to Handle Large Files
Share file packages of unlimited size and individual files of up to 15 TB.
File acceleration on a global scale; MASV supports transfers up to 10Gbps entirely over the cloud.
Easy to Use (For Everyone)
No IT set-up or staff training required. A clean, drag-and-drop interface. Available on any browser.
No Barriers to Collaboration
Create Teams and invite as many members as you need. We charge per Team not per user.
Large File Sharing For Less
Only pay for what you use at $0.25/GB downloaded — or buy data in bulk at a reduced rate.
Secure by Design
MASV is built from the ground up with a layered security approach baked right into the solution.
Amazing Workflow Features
Branded upload portals, cloud integrations, automations, and more!
Create cloud integrations, set-up automations, integrate with NAS, and more with our file transfer API.
We’re always available on our live customer support chat and 24/7 email support if you have questions.
Customers Who Switched to MASV
Hear stories from those who made the switch from Media Shuttle and Aspera to MASV.
When Aspera’s upload, download, and storage costs grew too expensive, Apache said goodbye – and hello to MASV.
Smart Post Atlanta
Learn how Smart Post Atlanta replaced its expensive, on-premises Aspera and Signiant instances with MASV web-based file transfer.
Get the inside track on why this sound studio ditched Aspera for a cheaper, easier alternative in MASV.
Learn why Simple DCP chose MASV after dealing with endless technical issues with other providers.
Make the Switch to MASV
Enjoy enterprise-grade file transfer without long sales cycles and complex IT environments.