Framing Britney Spears Editors on Documentary Storytelling | The Rough Cut

by Ankit Verma | August 4, 2021

As the legal battle between Britney Spears and her conservatorship rages on, and the #FreeBritney movement grows stronger, its clear that The New York Times/FX Networks-produced documentary, Framing Britney Spears is set to become a watershed piece of content.

The Rough Cut host, Matt Feury chats with the Emmy-nominated editors of Framing Britney Spears, Geoff O’Brien and Pierre Takal, on the editorial challenges of compressing twenty years of footage into a little more than an hour of screen time.

The episode explores several themes and challenges around documentary, including their editorial approach, the significance of audio manipulation in documentary storytelling, and challenges of crafting a compelling story out of so much raw footage.

Listen to the full interview ????

The Rough Cut is also available on:

Key conversations

*Quotes below have been edited for clarity and length.

Having a responsibility when editing

O’BRIEN: Sam [Stark, the film’s director-producer] wanted to reframe the way people looked at [Spears]. And I remember her also, in the beginning, saying we’re never going to use any archival of her as a joke—she’s never going to be the punchline of anything, [we’ll] never make an edit that does what everyone else has done to her, to take the cheap shots, or being too gratuitous. We knew that providing cultural context, and social context, and historical context would help round out the story of what had happened.

The challenge of editing 20 years of footage into an hour-long film

O’BRIEN: When we were first starting out we had a huge research team and a spreadsheet timeline of everything in her life, and any touchdown moments. And it was pages and pages long. We knew we couldn’t tell everything, but we had to show a lot of it… because we knew we wanted to show how things in succession affect somebody over time. Our first cut was a three-hour long edit.

But that three-hour cut, at the same time, was a hard watch. It was not easy to watch. Because there was a time when everybody just felt that they could say anything they wanted – and they did. So that was definitely a hard part of trying to figure out what to cut and what to leave.

On their editorial approach; reductive or additive?

O’BRIEN: I initially wanted to see everything, because I didn’t really know or had forgotten a lot of the story. I wanted to throw everything down and see it all from beginning to end. And then I realized, “Yeah, I’m three hours long, and this is never gonna work.”

TAKAL: It was actually a very interesting personal experience for me, because having worked at MTV on those clips shows and using some of that same footage I was seeing, and completely changing its meaning and not using it in an exploitive way, I’m guilty of being part of the machine that did the bad things. And that made working on this actually a wonderful personal experience—to use it in a different way. To reframe it, I guess.

Organizing and categorizing all that footage

O’BRIEN: We had all the media lumped into different buckets. But then you start looking through these bins and you realize (even some minor events) provide a good foreshadowing of what happens later in her life. So while this stuff was organized in a very logical manner, it didn’t always make sense as far as the emotional architecture of the script. And that was always challenging to say, “I know this isn’t a major part of her life, but it’ll actually help frame what’s to come.”

TAKAL: It’s hard to label things and put markers on things before you even start. How do you organize stuff when you don’t even know the story, and how it’s gonna play out? Obviously, if it’s scripted, then things are scene-based. But in this case you really need the freedom to discover things on your own.

The use of acoustic treatments and plugins

TAKAL: It’s important to not manipulate (interview audio), or do the least amount possible. One thing I always communicate to the mixer is that while we’re not manipulating anything, you can do a lot with levels. Audio is 80% of importance. When you have archival or news that’s interwoven in an interview, you make the interview the loudest. And then you have the stuff that’s interwoven at about 75%, volume-wise, so that you really follow the information that you’re supposed to get from the interview. The other stuff should never compete.

It’s a very subtle way of creating a sort of audio tapestry, where not everything is 100%, not every little sound up from the news is as important as the interview. But you’re not changing it at all. You’re just reducing the level.

???? The Rough Cut Podcast

The Rough Cut is sponsored by MASV, the fastest way to send and receive massive video files. Send uncompressed dailies, locked pictures, DCPs, and more with MASV. Sign up today and receive 100 GB free towards your next transfer.

Listen to past episodes:

Need to Send Large Files?

Create a free MASV account to get started

Photogrammetry, Virtual Sets, and the Future of Digital Data

If you're creating virtual environments, I could go in and shoot through photogrammetry and have a background and then use that later as a location. A simple explanation of that is a show called Station Eleven on HBO Max.

What is the 180-Degree Rule in Filmmaking?

The 180-degree rule is one of the most important rules for filmmakers. Breaking this rule can often lead to a viewer being disoriented.

How Hollywood is Using NFTs to Fund, Distribute, and Merchandise Films

If you could help finance the production of your favorite actor or director’s film by purchasing a non-fungible token (NFT), would you?

What is a Split Focus Diopter?

With modern cameras, it’s much easier to achieve a deep depth of field, but there’s still something to be said about the split focus diopter shots that we saw in early film.

Remote Production in 2022: Things to Consider

If 2021 was the year remote production became normalized, 2022 is when it becomes the de-facto way of work for Media and Entertainment (M&E). The “big” projects in M&E have been moving in this direction for sometime. Albeit slowly. In 2021, all aspects of production moved from the facilities to the WFH model making everyone a remote worker.

Creating the Metaverse with Volumetric Video and Virtual Production

The metaverse is one of those big, meaty concepts that tends to spur all kinds of debate. Sometimes practical, often theoretical. Or downright vague. And while some observers are hesitant and others gung-ho about the implications of the metaverse, many agree that the concept is a really big deal. Metastage is a company on the forefront of it all. Metastage provides state-of-the-art, 3D volumetric video capture and photorealistic virtual humans—and when paired with virtual production, is perfect for injecting into the metaverse as representations of real people. MASV spoke with Metastage CEO Christina Heller and Head of Production Skylar Sweetman to get their insights on how video producers can leverage the metaverse, what tools they can use to do it, and what it all means for M&E professionals and consumers.  Let’s dig in. Jump to section: What is the metaverse? How will people access and consume media in the...

The Evolution of Video Editing: From the Moviola to Machine Learning

It’s crazy to think about how far we’ve come in the evolution of video editing when you see how easy it is to cut and rearrange footage on your mobile phone nowadays. Video editors of today may be surprised to learn just how difficult video editing used to be—especially before the small miracle of non-linear editing (NLE) software. Indeed, the initial iteration of video editing before editing machines or software—heck, before even scissors and tape—consisted of a cameraperson holding the shot until precisely the right moment. That was it. Even the rudimentary concept of cuts didn’t yet exist. Fast forward to today, where machine learning and automation is replacing the more mundane (and sometimes painful) aspects of editing, like captioning and masking. The evolution of video editing has a rich history so let’s explore a timeline of highlights over the decades. Jump to section: The Dawn of Video Editing...

The Suicide Squad Editors on Constantly Being Surprised by James Gunn | The Rough Cut

From the hilariously deranged mind of James Gunn comes the new (and improved) The Suicide Squad—a zany and unpredictable anti-hero adventure that finds some of DC Comics most obscure characters getting their shot at redemption.   The Rough Cut host, Matt Feury chats with The Suicide Squad editors Fred Raskin, ACE, and Christian Wagner about working with writer/director James Gunn and experimenting with their preferred styles of editing. Listen to the full interview ???? The Rough Cut is also available on: Spotify Apple Podcasts Google Podcasts Stitcher Key conversations *Quotes below have been edited for clarity and length. Editing a trailer versus a feature-length film WAGNER: James Gunn and Peter Safran asked me to put together a promo trailer for Peacemaker while we were cutting The Suicide Squad. I, admittedly, wrote them back man and said, “listen, guys, I really don’t know how to do that stuff.” I have been...

‘Loki’ Editors on Bringing the TVA to Life | The Rough Cut

The God of Mischief has got himself into a bit of pickle after unknowingly causing the sacred timeline to branch out into a multiversal frenzy. The Rough Cut host, Matt Feury interviews a trio of Loki editors, Paul Zucker, ACE, Emma McCleave, and Callum Ross on their experience working on the hit Marvel show, which just wrapped up its Season 1 finale. Read More: ‘Black Widow’ Editors on Marvel’s First Feature-Length Film in Two Years Listen to the full interview ???? The Rough Cut is also available on: Spotify Apple Podcasts Google Podcasts Stitcher Key conversations Editing a pilot that isn’t a pilot ZUCKER: This wasn’t a pilot in the classic sense that we’re starting cold. Almost any Marvel project to a degree, we’re all stepping into a continuum. It’s already in progress in a way. In some ways that’s like a sequel, right? I had something to reference....

‘Black Widow’ Editors on Marvel’s First Feature-Length Film in Two Years | The Rough Cut

What better way to kickstart the appetite for cinema with a new entry into the Marvel Cinematic Universe? After being shelved for a year due to the closure of theatres, Black Widow is now playing on the big screen and is available for premium purchase at-home through Disney+. Fun fact: Marvel Studios didn’t release any films in 2020—the first time Marvel has missed a year since 2009 (break in-between Iron Man 1 and 2). The Rough Cut host, Matt Feury interviews Black Widow editors, Matthew Schmidt and Leigh Folsom Boyd on sharing editing duties on a Marvel blockbuster, working remotely during post-production, and their experience collaborating with director, Cate Shortland. Listen to the full interview ???? The Rough Cut is also available on: Spotify Apple Podcasts Google Podcasts Stitcher Key conversations Making blockbuster movies from home FEURY: What adjustments did you have to make once you went remote? Was...